Welcome – Salvatore Spadafora, Vice Dean Post MD 2015-2020
This academic year has been one of unprecedented change that has been equally challenging and rewarding. The unprecedented challenge for the delivery and reinvention of medical education as a result of COVID-19 saw Post MD Education come together as a community to respond to the needs, safety and wellness of our trainees and faculty while also fostering innovative new ways of learning.
Last year’s annual report reinforced the message that Post MD Education encourages a culture that endeavours “to teach our learners to be ready to take up the challenge of “jobs that have not been invented”, and “crises we can’t yet imagine.” The latter part of the 2019-2020 academic year introduced us to one such crisis with the COVID-19 global pandemic. The unprecedented challenge for the delivery and reinvention of medical education as a result of COVID-19 saw Post MD Education come together as a community to respond to the needs, safety and wellness of our trainees and faculty while also fostering innovative new ways of learning. We quickly mobilized to create an environment that functioned remotely, while maintaining the delivery of world class teaching and programs for trainees and learners.
With support from the Temerty Foundation, Continuing Professional Development (CPD) created a COVID-19 website to house curated education and clinical resources. A resource library was also developed to house over 180 curated resources from trusted sources and a special CPD response to COVID-19 fund was established to support research and innovation in education. Under the leadership of Dr. Julie Maggi, Post MD Education created a COVID-19 Wellness Webinar Series to support mental health and build resilience. The COVID-19 pandemic also propelled a transformational change in CPD programs and conferences with the transition to digital learning. The move to digital opened up opportunities for new formats and allowed CPD to work with a number of specialty societies and associations.
For Postgraduate Medical Education (PGME), this year marked its third successful year in the staged implementation of the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada (the Royal College) Competence by Design (CBD) model, with fourteen postgraduate programs newly onboarded (the largest cohort yet). PGME also continued to enhance the online platform, Elentra, to support the assessment of Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) and other workplace-based assessment tools. Furthermore, PGME continued to focus on the diversification of the sponsorship portfolio, and on the continuous improvement of the concierge service offered to sponsored applicants for postgraduate training. A central focus of the 2019-2020 academic year was on the preparation for our accreditation visit from the Royal College and the College of Family Physicians of Canada (CFPC) that took place as a virtual visit from November 22 – December 4, 2020.
This academic year has been one of unprecedented changes that has been equally challenging and rewarding. I completed my term as Vice Dean Post MD Education on June 30, 2020 and we welcomed Dr. Patricia Houston as Vice Dean, Medical Education, a new role within the Temerty Faculty of Medicine.
As I reflect on my past 10 years in the Temerty Faculty of Medicine, first as Vice Dean PGME and then as Vice Dean Post MD Education – PGME and CPD, I am grateful for the commitment and intellectual foresight of our leaders Drs. Suzan Schneeweiss, Glen Bandiera, our faculty members, staff, and affiliated hospital partners. I am proud of all we have been able to accomplish together and wish you all continued success.
Salvatore Spadafora
Vice-Dean Post MD 2015-2020
Welcome – Patricia Houston, Vice Dean Medical Education
Welcome to the 2019-2020 annual report for Post MD education. This report highlights some of the achievements across PGME and CPD. Much of the year was impacted by the COVID-19 global pandemic and the ways in which processes, systems and the delivery of education and care needed to pivot to meet the needs of our learners, our patients and their families.
Welcome to the 2019-2020 annual report for Post MD education. This report highlights some of the achievements across PGME and CPD. Much of the year was impacted by the COVID-19 global pandemic and the ways in which processes, systems and the delivery of education and care needed to pivot to meet the needs of our learners, our patients and their families.
Most of these changes occurred under the leadership of Dr. Salvatore Spadafora who completed his term as the Vice-Dean Post MD Education at the end of June. Dr. Spadafora brought a wealth of experience to the role, and developed key collaborations and partnerships across the Temerty Faculty of Medicine, nationally and internationally. I would like to thank Dr. Spadafora for his dedication, commitment and willingness to lead change over the past 10 years in PGME – first as Vice Dean PGME and then as Vice Dean Post MD Education – PGME and CPD. Under Dr. Spadafora, CPD and PGME were fully integrated as Post MD Education, a first step in recognizing the importance of the continuum of medical education.
My new role, Vice Dean, Medical Education, will allow us to develop alignment, integration and collaboration across the continuum of learners at the Temerty Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto. I look forward to learning from and working closely with these awesome teams to meet the needs of our learners and our community.
Patricia Houston
Vice Dean, Medical Education
Redeployment: Answering the Call in Times of Exceptional Need
Partnerships
COVID-19 presented many challenges to the clinical educational environment and beyond. PGME's acute response involved a three-phase redeployment plan guided by Principles for Redeployment and Procedural Memo developed in collaboration with hospital partners. PGME also leveraged its partnerships with provincial regulators and the Ontario Hospital Association to ensure that residents and fellows could safely undertake redeployment and/or continue into practice even though certification examinations were deferred.
Effective relationships and partnership structures served PGME well in responding to the COVID-19 pandemic. Through the Council of Ontario Faculties of Medicine (COFM), we worked closely with the provincial regulators and the Ontario Hospital Association (OHA) to ensure that residents and fellows could safely undertake redeployment and/or continue into practice even though certification examinations were deferred. Internal redeployment was managed actively through the education subcommittee of the Toronto Academic Health Science Network (TAHSNe). We collaborated with the national certifying Colleges to ensure modified curricula and experiential learning would not compromise learner progress. PGME also partnered with external providers and through the generosity of the Temerty Foundation was able to cover costs for learners requiring self-isolation due to work and who had at-risk family members at home.
COVID-19 presented many challenges to our clinical educational environment and beyond. Our acute response involved a three-phase redeployment plan guided by Principles for Redeployment and Procedural Memo developed in collaboration with our hospital partners. At the onset of the pandemic, dialogue was solution focused and many programs depended on internal redeployments; developing centralized cross-divisional and/or creative approaches as our trainees moved into isolation and quarantine. The departments of Medicine and Anesthesia proactively reallocated their residents to support and bolster ICUs. Surgery and Family Medicine departments also provided additional support where possible. In anticipation of a second wave and with an increase in clinical activity, PGME developed a balanced and systematic approach for phase two of the redeployment.
As part of a larger redeployment strategy, PGME worked collaboratively with program directors to identify availability of residents for each block of the 2020-2021 academic year. With this proactive groundwork, the rotating redeployment roster has been effective in addressing needs as they arise. As we navigate this new normal, flexibility and adaptability has been critical.
Adapting to the new normal – The Impact of COVID-19 on Post MD Education
COVID Shifts
The global pandemic required Post MD Education to quickly develop and deliver medical education in a new way. PGME worked closely with hospital sites and external partners to redeploy PG learners and quickly transitioned all learner-facing activities on-line. CPD rapidly developed capacity and expertise in the delivery of digital conferences. This move opened-up opportunities for new program and conference formats and collaboration with national specialty societies and associations.
The COVID-19 global pandemic required Post MD Education to quickly develop and deliver medical education in a new way. PGME undertook two main initiatives early in the COVID-19 pandemic to ensure optimum resident and fellow support and involvement. All learner-facing PGME office activities were quickly transitioned online, including the complex logistics of registering learners from around the world and providing one-on-one wellness support through the Post MD Wellness office. Although travel and VISA application restrictions complicated these processes, over 80% of new international trainees eventually arrived.
PGME also worked closely with our hospital sites and many external partners to redeploy PG learners. In order to ensure this response was done in alignment with appropriate regulations and constraints, a set of principles and a procedural guide that prioritized patient care and learner safety yet also respected educational continuity was developed. The TASHNe sub-committee was critical in addressing and implementing this redeployment strategy which resulted in over 250 residents providing service outside of their program or rotation during the first wave of the pandemic.
COVID-19 resulted in the cancelation and postponement of many live conferences and programs. While the CPD Office had a long history of offering webinar-style online programs, the complexity of delivering conferences that replicated attending a live in-person event required a major pivot. CPD had to rapidly develop capacity and expertise in the delivery of digital conferences and programs.
Recognizing the importance of delivering a high-quality learner experience, CPD procured a conference platform that allowed for integrated live-streaming of sessions, workshops, attendee networking, posters, and sponsor exhibit halls. Digital conference delivery more resembles a live television broadcast than a traditional hotel-based conference. This shift necessitated the retooling of the existing CPD team into digital producers, technical directors and stage managers.
The move to a digital space also opened up opportunities for new program and conference formats. For example, one group reworked their annual conference format into a 22-part series which featured over 300 presenters. Another group developed a year-long series that will culminate into a replica of their annual meeting. CPD also partnered with a number of national specialty societies and associations.
Promoting Wellness Across the Continuum of Medical Education
Wellness
Wellness webinars and online workshops delivered essential education to the U of T health care community. CPD offered two series covering topics including Mental Health & Resilience and Self-Care and Diversity. PGME’s wellness office developed a workshop and several videos to support wellness for trainees.
As many of our residents and trainees were at the frontline during the first wave of the pandemic, ensuring their wellness needs were met became a top priority. The Postgraduate Wellness Office (PWO) supported the development and implementation of accommodations for postgraduate trainees at increased risk for serious health consequences from COVID-19. The office is working to ensure that postgraduate trainees are supported in line with the Guidelines for Trainees at Risk during COVID-19. These guidelines were established by an expert panel led by Dr. Matthew Muller.
The office also developed a workshop for postgraduate trainees: Residency during the COVID-19 Pandemic: Coping with Uncertainty and Change which has become the most frequently subscribed workshop by residency training programs during the pandemic. Additionally, the office created several videos to support wellness including an overview of PWO services for trainees and coping during the pandemic. The office has reached out to postgraduate trainees in quarantine, and redeployed trainees, to offer support, connection to services and information and continues to provide consultation to programs in collaboration with the PGMEAC Wellness subcommittee to support the wellness needs arising during the pandemic.
For the CPD community, two webinars series’ addressed the pressing issues that were raised in the early part of the year, delivering essential education for the University of Toronto health care community. Conceived by the COVID Clinical Faculty Wellness Working Group, the first series included 8 webinars with speakers from across the country covering topics of Mental Health & Resilience, Self-Care, Racism & Discrimination, Compassion Fatigue, Exercise & Nutrition, Sleep Health, Parenting, and Intimate Partner Violence. Learner interest and engagement for this series was strong. The average live audience was over 425 and an average of 160 viewed the recording. Many sessions ran overtime when trying to answer the large number of audience questions. The positive evaluation feedback along with numerous topic suggestions for future sessions show an appetite for future iterations of the wellness series.
The second series, Dialogues in Diversity, focused on Equity Diversity and Inclusion (EDI) and featured conversations among leading academics, EDI practitioners and social justice advocates whose work reflects the realities of COVID-19 and the challenges now being faced. Organized by the Centre for Innovation & Excellence in Child & Family-Centred Care at the Hospital for Sick Children, the series provided interactive and engaging space to support the critical analysis necessary to successfully address the social, economic and cultural inequities, now exacerbated by COVID-19. The series was presented via seven bi-weekly webinars in July and August and featured a wide range of topics such as neurodiversity, allyship and accommodation for remote work. Speakers included well known leaders in the EDI community including Dr. Pamela D. Palmater, Dr. Denise O'Neil Green and Dr. Roberta K. Timothy.
In total, over 2,500 attendees participated in this webinar series, and the initiative received very positive feedback. The success of the series has prompted organizers to continue delivering this important content and they are currently working on a similar series, planned for the spring of 2021.
Scholarship and Research across Post MD
Scholarship
Post MD was actively engaged in scholarship activities for the 2019-2020 academic year. Representatives participated several medical education conferences including AMEE, ICRE, CCME and SACME. Research topics explored ideas of how to lead and sustain successful change and educational technology.
PGME has been actively involved in scholarly activities in the 2019-2020 academic year. Representatives from the PGME office participated in four medical education conferences: the Association for Medical Education in Europe (AMEE), the International Conference on Residency Education (ICRE), the Canadian Conference on Medical Education (CCME), and the University of Toronto, Temerty Faculty of Medicine Physician Health Symposium. Much of the year’s scholarly activities explored ideas of change — how to lead and sustain successful change, understanding and adapting to new national accreditation standards, exploring competency frameworks and faculty development as medical education moves into the competency-based model, identifying a need for change in how we support underrepresented residents in Canada, what can we change to better support resident wellness and residents in academic difficulty, and asking: are we ready for the change that is to come? A complete overview of the presentations, paper presentations, workshops, and posters can be viewed online.
The CPD Research & Scholarship team was pleased to adjudicate two rounds of funding in 2019-2020. The CPD Research and Development Grants were awarded in December 2019 to 5 successful project teams. A list of grant recipients and information about future funding cycles are available online. A further 7 projects were funded in Spring 2020 through the CPD COVID-19 Response Fund which was established with the support of the Temerty Foundation and additional CPD funding.
New scholarly projects include the evaluation of the revised Leading and Influencing Change program and a research project exploring what leadership means in the context of CPD (PI: Dr. David Wiljer) as well as a needs assessment for preparing CPD leaders to develop programs using educational technology (PI: Dr. Heather MacNeill).
Research dissemination continues, with affiliated faculty and staff presentation at the National Accreditation Conference held in Ottawa, Ontario in October 2019, the SACME Conference held in Miami in February 2020, and at the AMEE conference held virtually in September 2020. Recently published works include a study led by Dr. Katie Lundon characterizing the Canadian workforce attributes of extended role practitioners (ERPs) in arthritis care, and a study on Microlearning in CPD led by past Leading Change participant Dr. Helena Filipe.
Financial gift establishes priority fund to support CPD and PGME activities
Financial Support
The University of Toronto’s Temerty Faculty of Medicine has received a $10-million gift from the Temerty Foundation to support Toronto’s hospital and health-science network as it responds to the COVID-19 pandemic. Received in early April, the gift was committed to create the Dean’s COVID-19 Priority Fund. This priority fund directly supports a number of CPD and PGME activities.
The University of Toronto’s Temerty Faculty of Medicine has received a $10-million gift from the Temerty Foundation to support Toronto’s hospital and health-science network as it responds to the COVID-19 pandemic. Received in early April, the gift was committed to create the Dean’s COVID-19 Priority Fund. This priority fund directly supports a number of CPD and PGME activities.
With support from the fund, the CPD team pivoted to support physician education around COVID-19. CPD established an internal working group who worked closely with the CPD leads in the clinical departments to coordinate efforts and develop general and specialty-specific education initiatives. Activities included the development of a COVID-19 Website to serve as hub for education and clinical resources, creation of a COVID-19 Resource Library, a searchable database containing 180 curated resources and clinical supports from trusted sources; including both general and specialty-specific resources as well as information to support virtual care and wellness, delivery of a COVID-19 Webinar Series, which offered 44 different webinars on a range of topics including variety of specialty-specific clinical topics related to COVID-19, virtual care, wellness, COVID-19 impact on care for adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities (IDD), and the equity diversity and inclusion (EDI) implications of COVID-19, establishment of a special CPD Response to COVID-19 Fund (CPD-CRF) to support research and innovation in education and support for program directors and conference chairs in transitioning to a virtual learning environment.
This investment helped to establish isolation housing for medical residents and fellows, provided emergency student funds for those impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic and supported professional development for clinicians and traineeswho found themselves navigating unfamiliar areas of health care due to redeployment, such as the ICU or palliative medicine.
Residents and Fellows from across the province, the country and international jurisdictions come to the University of Toronto to experience a unique breadth and depth of clinical experiences and to work with some of the leading clinicians and researchers in their field.
While the number of visiting electives peaked in 2017-18, we continue to welcome almost 800 learners from other jurisdictions to U of T programs and affiliated training sites.
Department
2019-20
2018-19
2017-18
Anesthesia
18
17
37
Critical Care
24
20
34
Diagnostic Radiology
17
13
16
Family Medicine
40
53
34
Laboratory Medicine
21
35
37
Medicine
322
427
455
Obstetrics & Gynaecology
42
44
53
Ophthalmology
16
10
13
Otolarnygology
7
3
8
Pediatrics
127
191
200
Psychiatry
21
28
24
Public Health & Preventive Medicine
3
5
3
Radiation Oncology
11
12
12
Surgery
119
106
153
Grand Total
788
964
1079
In part, as a result of the disruption for Saudi trainees in their ability to continue training at Canadian institutions, we did observe a decline in the number of internationally sponsored residents and fellows from that jurisdiction in 2019-20, after steady growth from 2015-16. Notwithstanding this disruption, we continue to welcome international candidates from Kuwait, Oman, UAE and several other jurisdictions.
Country
2019-20
2018-19
2017-18
2016-17
2015-16
Bahrain
8
5
3
1
0
Kuwait
38
36
27
33
33
Oman
31
30
29
29
29
Qatar
1
1
2
2
4
Saudi
168
231
234
238
191
UAE
17
15
14
13
16
Other
0
2
1
1
1
Total
263
320
310
317
274
On March 3rd, 2020, the University of Toronto filled all 407 PGY1 entry residency positions in the first iteration of CaRMS. This included 337 positions for Canadian medical graduates and another 70 positions for International Medical Graduates.
Of the 337 Canadian medical graduates, approximately 39% were U of T medical students. A further 38% were from other Ontario schools, 22% from other Canadian schools and 2% from U.S. schools. Of the IMGs matched, the majority obtained their MD in Ireland (38%), followed by Southeast Asia at 14.5%, the Middle East at 13% and the U.K at almost 12%.
Country
Total
Australia
3
Ireland
26
South America
3
Caribbean
5
Eastern Europe
2
Middle East
9
Russia
1
UK
8
Western Europe
1
Mexico
1
Southeast Asia
10
Total
69
Toronto
130
Ontario Other
127
Canada Other
74
United States
6
IMGs
70
Total
337
After a period of steady growth in the number of MOH funded residency positions, we saw a decline in positions corresponding to the Ministry imposed reduction to residency intake, implemented in 2016-17. Subsequent reductions were mitigated by the initiative to provide 16 additional opportunities to unmatched U of T medical students to train in U of T residency programs.
The distribution of growth has been uneven across departments with growth in departments such as DFCM, Medicine and Psychiatry and reductions in departments such as Surgery, Anesthesia and Lab Medicine.
Growth in MOH funded PGYs by Department
Department
2020 - 2021
2019 - 2020
2018 - 2019
2017 - 2018
2016 - 2017
2015 - 2016
2014 - 2015
2013 - 2014
2012 - 2013
2011 - 2012
Total
Surgery
214,68
209,19
212
217,79
223,73
226,36
236,93
235,62
225,99
238,69
2240,98
Radiation Oncology
19
16
16
18,93
20
22,93
24,91
24,19
23,13
22,74
207,83
Public Health & Preventive Med
11,08
9,79
11,38
11,49
18,54
17,99
17,79
16,67
20,24
25,21
160,18
Psychiatry
197,94
185,41
186,93
181,16
178,23
177,17
172,45
167,65
164,27
160,58
1771,79
Palliative Mediciine
0
0
0
0,07
3,94
3,14
4,04
3,77
3,16
2,84
20,96
Paeds Critical Care
4
4
4
4
4
1
1
2,49
3,83
1,89
30,21
Paediatrics
126,1
123,99
121,99
118,2
120,16
120,85
126,91
124,41
112,62
122,14
1217,37
Otolaryngology
24
25,5
22,77
26
26,25
26,99
25
24,29
24
26,45
251,25
Ophthalmology
24,08
24,5
24,64
24,72
24,33
23,3
26
26,76
24,04
24,64
247,01
Obstetrics & Gynaecology
72,52
72,89
68,9
72,72
73,95
76,3
70,73
69,6
64,93
58,92
701,46
Medicine
466,27
477,68
463,72
475,59
478,61
485,72
467,78
442,38
443,16
435,39
4636,3
Medical Genetics
11
10,5
9,02
8,94
8,86
9,09
9,84
11,15
9,01
8,22
95,63
Laboratory Medicine
36,32
35,82
37,27
41,5
38,08
40,4
36,95
43
51,04
48,14
408,52
Family Medicine
372,16
385,09
376,41
367,54
366,68
365,64
355,28
372,92
343,61
318,01
3623,34
Diagnostic Radiology
57,94
61,34
63,46
64,77
71,51
67,37
61,44
62,33
65,86
69,57
645,59
Critical Care
14,92
14,46
12,5
12,14
14,36
13,78
12,59
13
16,56
14,55
138,86
Anesthesia
89,23
91,19
84,84
93,01
103,44
99,16
100,23
96,94
93,48
92,93
944,45
Total
1741,24
1747,35
1715,83
1738,57
1774,67
1777,19
1749,87
1737,17
1688,93
1670,91
17341,73
Message from the Associate Dean, CPD
CPD
The COVID-19 pandemic has been transformational for CPD. Over the past year, we have successfully pivoted to a new way of learning and conveyed to learners across the continuum of medical education the value of lifelong learning.
The COVID-19 pandemic has been transformational for CPD. Over the past year, we have successfully pivoted to a new way of learning and conveyed to learners across the continuum of medical education the value of lifelong learning. With a renewed focus on technology, CPD has been able to demonstrate effective ways of learning in the digital environment to ensure the health and safety of our healthcare professionals. I would like to congratulate the entire CPD team for their leadership in rendering this effort a tremendous success.
Dr. Suzan Schneeweiss
Associate Dean, Continuing Professional Development
CPD Programs Offer Pathway For New Credential
Leadership
The Certified Professional in CPD (Healthcare) credential is a new formal designation for those engaged professionally in the discipline of CPD. It recognizes the achievement of CPD leaders, program developers, researchers and administrators, whether physicians or non-physicians and will launch in early 2021.
The Certified Professional in CPD (Healthcare) credential is a new formal designation for those engaged professionally in the discipline of CPD. It recognizes the achievement of CPD leaders, program developers, researchers and administrators, whether physicians or non-physicians and will launch in early 2021.
This new credential was created by the Coalition for Physician Learning and Practice Improvement, a group of eight leading physician medical associations, federations and colleges in Canada. It was developed based on the recommendations put forth in the 2019 Future of Medical Education in Canada (FMEC) CPD report. The report describes a new CPD system that supports physician learning and practice improvement and sustains innovation and quality improvement for the health of Canadians. This credential offers one approach to achieve this end.
CPD had been working closely with the Coalition to create a pathway for those interested in the credential. Through the certificate route, CPD professionals who complete both CPD Foundations and the Leading and Influencing Change in CPD programs offered by CPD are eligible to be considered for the credential. The leadership route offers those with senior leadership experience in CPD another avenue to apply. Complete details about the credential, the application process and review can be found on the Coalition website set to launch in early January.
Teaching and Learning in the Pandemic- Past, Present and Future
Innovation
With grant funding from the Coalition for Physician Learning and Practice Improvement, a 7-video series on Synchronous (Live Online) Teaching and Learning in Healthcare which covers online learning, effective teaching principles, co-facilitation, and interactivity in Zoom has been created. The tips highlighted through the series cover what you need to know before teaching online.
The COVID-19 pandemic caused a rapid shift to “emergency” online teaching particularly in synchronous (webinar) environments, with limited preparation of teachers and learners in March 2020. As well, the CPD landscape abruptly pivoted from face-to-face (F2F) to online due to social distancing and travel restrictions. With these rapid changes came an opportunity for the Office of CPD to help by preparing our teacher, presenters, learners, facilitators & moderators for this new learning environment across the healthcare system.
We have released a 7-video series on Synchronous (Live Online) Teaching and Learning in Healthcare which covers online learning, effective teaching principles, co-facilitation, and interactivity in Zoom. Whether you a presenter, co-facilitator, or moderator, the tips highlighted through this educator series will cover what you need to know before teaching online. We are grateful for grant funding from the Coalition for Physician Learning and Practice Improvement for this project and to our colleagues at UGME and CFD who collaborated in the process.
The Educator Series videos cover Introduction to Synchronous Online Learning, Getting Started, featuring audio / video / internet setup, Online Interactivity, featuring screen sharing, annotation, & whiteboards, Feedback, featuring chat, participant pod & polls, Collaborative and Social Learning, featuring netiquette & online communication, Reflection, featuring breakout rooms and Co-facilitation and Moderating Sessions. The Learner Series, how to learn effectively in a synchronous environment will be released in the new year.
Enabling Scientific Planning Committees in the transition to virtual learning
Community
CPD has significantly evolved its operations to support the transition of primarily on-site CPD to virtual learning, increasing access to education and accreditation consultation services. Since March, the CPD Accreditation Team has been providing as many as half-dozen consults each day to Scientific Planning Committees (SPC).
CPD has significantly evolved its operations to support the transition of primarily on-site CPD to virtual learning, increasing access to education and accreditation consultation services. Since March, the CPD Accreditation Team has been providing as many as half-dozen consults each day to Scientific Planning Committees (SPC).
One primary focus area for these consults has been enabling the SPC to identify strategic choices of active learning opportunities in the virtual environment, such as multiple forms of polling, chats, and the thoughtful use of breakout rooms. Another prime area for consultation focuses on continuing the strong collegial collaborations and community of practices that typify CPD activities into the virtual environment. Creating opportunities for sharing and developing mutual supports in addressing challenges facing health providers, their patients and communities is important to all.
Another area of frequent consult is supporting SPCs to develop programs that fully meet accreditation requirements for a virtual program. For example, many consults focus on the retention of the high-quality academic content and integrity while balancing the appropriate acknowledgement of sponsors in a virtual environment. Likewise, as we begin to move away from COVID-specific material which was offered and accredited often at no cost to programs and participants, accreditation consults now often focus on achieving a balance between a registration fee requirement for accredited programming with program fee structures in the virtual environment. As we continue to see, Program Directors, Faculty, Educational Teams, Sponsors, and CPD Participants are turning a challenge amid a crisis into opportunities to build more accessible and more effective CPD.
Message from the Associate Dean, PGME
PGME
PGME has had a unique role in the pandemic. As both learners and health care providers, our residents and fellows stepped up to provide care in unorthodox models and in expanded roles.
PGME has had a unique role in the pandemic. As both learners and health care providers, our residents and fellows stepped up to provide care in unorthodox models and in expanded roles. PGME oversaw more than 450 redeployments in the first wave including systematized simulation-based PPE training and has implemented a structured outbreak management and redeployment framework for the second wave. Furthermore, our learners have adapted to a virtual environment for much of their formalized learning. On top of all of this, our programs have moved forward with Competency-Based Education launches and prepared and underwent a full accreditation review - all done virtually for the first time in Canada. It has been a time of immense strain, but it has brought out the best in our academically minded and creative faculty, staff and learners. It makes me proud to be part of such an amazing environment.
Dr. Glen Bandiera
Associate Dean, Postgraduate Medical Education
Adjusting to New Processes
Community
COVID-19 required Canadian medical schools to quickly adapt to the repercussions for both medical students and residents seeking entry and subspecialty residency positions. New virtual processes were introduced for CaRMS to help residency programs adapt to a very different process of selecting candidates for their programs.
COVID-19 required Canadian medical schools to quickly adapt to the repercussions for both medical students and residents seeking entry and subspecialty residency positions. Similarly, residency programs had to adapt to a very different process of selecting candidates for their programs.
Throughout the Spring of 2020, the Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada (AFMC) Residency Matching Committee (ARMC) convened working groups to address a compressed CaRMS timeline, the challenge of virtual interviews and virtual program promotion and applications and file review. PGME at the University of Toronto is well represented on the ARMC by Dr. Glen Bandiera as PG Dean and Caroline Abrahams as a representative for national PG Managers.
As a result of the national efforts, key changes were made to CaRMS processes including: virtual interviews only for the Fall 2020 Medical Subspecialty, Pediatric Subspecialty and Family Medicine -Enhanced Skills CaRMS matches; a delayed and compressed 2021 PGY1 match which begins for residency programs with file review starting February 8th and a first iteration match day on April 20th, online tools for programs to promote their events and features to candidates and more national standardization and structure of key documents used to assess suitability of applicants for programs.
PGME is supporting our residency programs during this challenging time by continuing to offer our Best Practices on Application and Selection workshops with updated content to assist programs with strategies and techniques in this unique environment. In addition, we are providing support and training for program selection committees to ensure they are attentive to equity, diversity and inclusion principles and that members are aware of conflict of interest guidelines and declarations.
The PGME and MD programs also adapted their upcoming accreditation visits to fit with the current COVID-19 restrictions. Both visits this Fall were held virtually. The PGME accreditation visit was conducted by the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada and the College of Family Physicians of Canada from Sunday, November 22nd to Friday December 4th. The visit was extended to two weeks long to accommodate the new virtual format. PGME programs and committees were busy preparing documents and over 100 different schedules as all active programs (residency and AFC) and the PG institution were reviewed during this two-week period. We are confident that our programs and institution put their best foot forward as they took part in this continuous improvement process.
Postgraduate Medicine Leadership Certificate Program: Building on Success
Leadership
The Postgraduate Medicine Leadership Certificate Program (PGLC) is a program that is unique to Canada designed to foster medical leadership. Founded on the understanding that all physicians are leaders and play an important leadership role in health care, the PGLC is a centralized offering from PGME that fills a gap for trainees seeking to enhance their leadership capabilities through innovative learning and development of a relevant action learning project.
The Postgraduate Medicine Leadership Certificate Program (PGLC) is founded on the understanding that all physicians are leaders and play an important leadership role in health care. The PGLC is a centralized offering from PGME that fills a gap for trainees seeking to enhance their leadership capabilities through innovative learning and development of a relevant action learning project.
Applications for the second iteration of the program were triple those of last year, attesting to positive reports from the first group of participants, and increasing recognition of the role leadership plays in optimizing quality health care for individual patients and for society as a whole. Building on the success of last year and to meet the increased demand, the total number of participants was increased to 31, and for the first time included fellows.
The course was successfully adapted to a virtual platform and continued to feature informal fireside chats with medical leaders and interactive workshops. Educational imperatives such as ‘Leadership through an EDI Lens’ were added to this year’s curriculum. The online offering has afforded the opportunity to invite all undergraduate and postgraduate medical learners to the fireside chats, and to launch a synchronous satellite pilot at Queen’s University with 6 trainees and a local supervisor. In response to feedback from last year’s participants a facilitated small group mentorship program, which combines small-group networking with faculty mentorship, was started. The University of Toronto’s Postgraduate Medicine Leadership Certificate Program is unique in Canada and we are proud of its role in fostering medical leadership.
Personal Protective Equipment (PPE): Pivoting to a new normal for COVID-19 safety
Innovation
The COVID-19 pandemic forced the PGME team to reconsider the training needs of current PGME trainees. In March and April, COVID-19 resources such as establishment of goals of care and management of the critically ill patient with COVID-19 were curated and posted on the PGME website; many of the resources were adapted specifically to the University of Toronto context.
The COVID-19 pandemic forced the PGME team to reconsider the training needs of current PGME trainees. In March and April, COVID-19 resources such as establishment of goals of care and management of the critically ill patient with COVID-19 were curated and posted on the PGME website; many of the resources were adapted specifically to the University of Toronto context.
Next, PGME supported the practical training of residents and fellows for clinical redeployment as required to meet COVID-19 service needs. With the help of Dr. Filipe Santos from the Department of Anesthesia and in collaboration with TAHSN simulation centres at Mount Sinai hospital, Sunnybrook Health Science centre and Unity Health systems, trainees received practical training in the safe donning and doffing of personal protective equipment (PPE), including for Protected Code Blue. The focus of training was on residents involved in internal redeployment and those on the PGME redeployment list which included the following departments: Anesthesia, Otolaryngology/Head & Neck Surgery, Department of Surgery, Neuroradiology, Obstetrics, Ophthalmology, Diagnostic Radiology, Family Medicine, Medical Genetics and Dermatology.
In June, our attention shifted to prepare incoming PGME trainees for their July start. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic and restricted clinical activities in the Spring, many trainees were entering residency with potential gaps in clinical training and encountering new infection control guidelines. To ensure their safety, a two-pronged approach was taken: a PPE Virtual Orientation and In-Person PPE Trainings at their training site. The Virtual Orientation included i) an infection control seminar about the ‘new normal’ clinical setting, ii) a video on human factors to enhance PPE safety, and iii) a knowledge and skills check with attestation that all components were completed.
Pivoting to meet our trainees’ needs during COVID-19 was done expeditiously and successfully. Over 300 residents/fellows received simulated training on PPE Safety, and an additional 100 participated in the virtual orientation. We were pleased to support, and continue to support the PGME trainees to function safely in the ‘new normal’.
Thank You & Acknowledgements
Thank you to the all of the staff at Post MD for their contribution to the continued success of the unit.
Thank you also to the Annual Report Working Group and those who contributed to the content and design of this year’s report – Caroline Abrahams, Glen Bandiera, Lisa Bevacqua, Trevor Cuddy, Karma Farah, Adrienne Fung, Susan Glover-Takahashi, Marta Guzik-Eldridge, Vashty Hawkins, Kate Hodgson, Patricia Houston, Melissa Hynes, Mikahla Iuele, Matt Jiggins, Renice Jones, Heather MacNeill, Julie Maggi, Anne Matlow, Maureen Morris, Laura Leigh Murgaski, Morag Paton, Hinal Pithia, Linda Probyn, Suzan Schneeweiss, Sal Spadafora, Jennifer Toulmin, Shantel Walcott and Brien Wong.
Post MD Education
Temerty Faculty of Medicine,
University of Toronto
500 University Avenue, 6th Floor
Toronto, ON M5G 1V7